AMERICAN ANGUS ASSOCIATION - THE BUSINESS BREED

Who Will Take Over?

Mentorship is key to bringing the next generation back to the farm to rebuild the herd.

June 1, 2024

by Joann Pipkin

Who will take over the farm? It’s a question that faces the cattle industry given an aging population of chief operators.

It’s a question Deb Thummel and husband Jeff wanted to address sooner rather than later. The Thummels run a diversified commercial Angus cow-calf, backgrounding and row-crop operation in northwest Missouri and southwest Iowa. They also have a consumer-direct fed-beef business and a growing Angus seedstock operation.

As fifth-generation cattle producers, the Thummels had seen firsthand the advantages of a farm transition plan. According to Thummel, the inconvenient conversations of succession planning far outweigh the sheer reality of never having the discussion in the first place.

“My parents had worked through those inconvenient conversations in the early 2000s. When Dad passed away in 2015, the plan worked well — both on paper and in real time,” Thummel explains.

With three grown children, two of whom are actively involved in the family business, the Thummels are a shining exception to data summarized in Industry Insights Powered by Angus Media and CattleFax, a survey of cow-calf producers and feedlot operators.

As outlined in the survey, only 36.4% of cow-calf producers have a written succession plan, compared to 63.6% of respondents who do not. A slightly higher number of feedyard owners — 38% — had a written succession plan.

So, who is taking over the farm? The data only fuel that burning question. Without clear direction of a transition for cow-calf and feedlot operations in the future, the fate of the industry as it tries to ignite another cattle cycle is unclear.

Yet, cattlemen across the country who are willing to put forth a well-thought plan are able and willing to mentor those passionate about the industry. Those open to diversifying the farm business can help bring the next generation back to the farm.

Start the conversation

As Industry Insights outlines, an overwhelming 73.7% of respondents are planning to transition the farm or ranch to family members (see Fig. 1). But, how does that happen? Where do you begin laying the foundation for farm succession?

Cattle on the cover of the Feed-calf Marketing Guide

Feeder-Calf Marketing Guide

This story was featured in the June 2024 Feeder-Calf Marketing Guide

Thummel-Farms

Deb & Jeff Thummel

The Thummels’ transition plan is currently marked by two living trusts, which Thummel says gives her and her husband flexibility to update assets and circumstances as situations change.

Still, starting the farm transition conversation between children, other family members or even employees can be awkward.

“Our job is to equip them and encourage them to be better than us. We must let them question us, our management and our motives, and we must give them honest answers.”

— Deb Thummel

Families grow, making succession planning more complex and ever-evolving. Pictured are (front row, from left) Ivory, Lydia, Hunter Stockhorst (apprentice), Chase; (second row) Austin, Kylee, Daylee, Kipton, Kate, Anne, Rebecca, (third row) Deb, Sydney and fiancé Bryce Long,  and (top) Jeff Thummel.

Families grow, making succession planning more complex and ever-evolving. Pictured are (front row, from left) Ivory, Lydia, Hunter Stockhorst (apprentice), Chase; (second row) Austin, Kylee, Daylee, Kipton, Kate, Anne, Rebecca, (third row) Deb, Sydney and fiancé Bryce Long, and (top) Jeff Thummel. 

Fig. 1: Who will likely take over the farm/ranch at the next transition?

Fig. 1: Who will likely take over the farm/ranch at the next transition?

“We considered the factors of who wanted to be involved in the future of the operation and how our trusts could be structured to meet the needs for those in the next generation that wanted to be physically active in the business and those that did not,” Thummel says.

Transition is certainly less complex when the next generation clearly wants to be involved in the family business.

While he doesn’t have a formal, written transition plan in place, northeastern Utah feedlot owner Brent Gillman says he’s already begun discussing plans with his children, three of whom are in college and one who has yet to graduate high school.

“I’m hoping that we can continue to have this be a family operation and transition it to one of them, similar to what my father did with me,” Gillman explains.

However, he says, that transition will likely include a couple of caveats:

  • Work for someone else for a couple of years before coming back to the operation.
  • Establish a plan to help grow revenue for the business.

“It’s different working for Mom and Dad than it is working for someone else,” Gillman says. “I think that would be a good learning experience for them. Then, when they come back, they kind of have a plan.”

Starting the conversation need not begin when children reach high school or college, though. Consider the J.H. Minor Co., an Angus cow-calf operation in the Nebraska Sandhills. Fourth-generation rancher Joe Minor owns and operates the ranch, along with the help of wife Kristi; son Tyler and his wife, McKenzie; as well as Tyler and McKenzie’s two young children, Talon and Hannah.

Minor sees value in getting his children involved in the operation from a young age, including them in ranch tasks they find interesting.

“Bringing the next generation into the operation instills our ‘why’ in them,” Minor says. “Why we get up every day and do what we do. We want to keep the legacy alive. No, this lifestyle isn’t for everyone, but it’s self-gratifying, and we hope to pass that down to the next generation.”

Mentor the committed

South Dakota feedlot owner John Moes built his operation from scratch in 1987 after leaving the family’s dairy to work for a grain and beef cattle farmer. The experience would serve him well over the years, as son Bryan now works alongside him in the business he crafted from infancy.

With the proverbial “farm transition” discussion already laid out, Moes is ready for the next step in building a succession plan. As he does so, he hopes to glean insight from industry experts while giving his son some real hands-on experience.

The Moes believe much insight on transition planning can be gained from succession and legacy experts like Jolene Brown, Alan Hojer, Ron Hanson and others.

While 59% of feedlot owners are age 60 and older (see Fig. 2) and 56.1% of cow-calf operators expect to change farm or ranch ownership in the next five to 19 years (see Fig. 3), according to the survey, training the next generation for the takeover must be realized.

Fig. 2: Age of current owner

Fig. 2: Age of current owner

Fig. 3: Within how many years do you expect your farm/ranch to change ownership?

Fig. 3: Within how many years do you expect your farm/ranch to change ownership?

“Dad’s done a good job stepping back and letting someone take over,” says Bryan Moes. “He’s been bringing the next generation into the operation and giving them hands-on experience to make some decisions while he’s there to guide.”

Moes goes on to say transitioning with a coach or guide in place helps smooth any bumps in the road.

“Having a mentor, someone to provide verbal reassurance, is a big hurdle (in transitioning the farm),” Moes says. “We’re as connected as ever with technology, but we’re more isolated in our silo, too.”

Tyler Minor agrees.

Tyler is actively involved in the family’s cow-calf operation, including the day-to-day decisions. Still, he knows there’s more behind the scenes to managing the operation.

“Running the operation isn’t just about the outside duties,” he explains. “It’s about money management and making smart decisions, as well.”

As critical as mentorship is, cultivating an innate passion for the industry is perhaps equally as important in bringing the next generation back to the farm.

“We’ve had little conversations with our kids about what they want to do when they get older,” Tyler says. “Yes, we want them to come back to the ranch, but we want them to choose this life because they want to.”

Virginia cow-calf producer Rusty Atkins instilled in his children from a young age that they must want to be involved in the operation for that transition to be carried out.

“If they don’t want to do it, they don’t have to,” Atkins explains. “That is their decision. But I’m not going to pass it on if they don’t have the same love for it.”

Thummel adds, “Their heart must be in it. No amount of encouragement or enticement will produce a heart intent on farming.”

Realizing that it can sometimes be difficult to always be optimistic in agriculture, she says the industry needs the energy and enthusiasm of the next generation.

“We must let them manage a little or a lot, even while we’re still here, even if there is an occasional loss or more than occasional loss,” she says. “Our job is to equip them and encourage them to be better than us. We must let them question us, our management and our motives, and we must give them honest answers.”

Fig. 4: Rate the following options as to their potential to challenge your operation's future

Fig. 4: Rate the following options as to their potential to challenge your operation's future

Prepare to diversify

The industry question at hand is more than just who is taking over the farm. The present-day difficulty of keeping farm operations out of the red is no secret. More than 58% of Industry Insights survey respondents cited input costs as a major concern for the industry (see Fig. 4). Another 46.1% identified farm profitability as an area of uneasiness.

Farm organizations like the Livestock Marketing Association (LMA) are taking notice. The group sees a continued loss of livestock producers across the United States as a critical threat to both the livestock industry and the nation’s food supply. An initiative launched by LMA last fall aims to help strengthen producer profitability and create incentives for the next generation of farmers and ranchers.

Producer Profitability Initiative organizer Joe Goggins, owner of Public Auction Yards, Billings, Mont., cites a lack of access to land and labor, overregulation and input costs as reasons for more cattlemen exiting the business while preventing new producers from getting started.

As beef producers continually seek out ways to add revenue to the bottom line, diversifying their operations provides a means of doing just that while also creating an avenue for the next generation to come back to the farm.

“When anyone is being added to the operation, remember it is a business,” Gillman says. “What skills do they have that can be an asset? Do they have work experience at a similar operation?”

Diversifying the farm business brought flexibility to the Thummel operation.

“If all eggs aren’t in one basket, the entire operation stands a better chance of surviving the shakes and drops in the industry,” Deb explains.

With their operation diversified in both crop and livestock enterprises, then further by backgrounding, direct-to-consumer, seedstock and cow-calf components, Thummel says their succession plan includes details to address each entity, allowing additional flexibility moving forward.

“Jeff and I are intentionally helpful to the custom-farming components that the next generation is adding to the overall diversity of the entire operation’s scope,” she says.

In addition to their feedlot, the Moes manage row-crop and cow-calf enterprises, retaining ownership of their fed cattle.

The whole systems approach to their feedyard allows for greater cash flow, Bryan Moes explains. “[In our business], if you aren’t diversified, you’re leaving value on the table.”

Living a legacy

A fifth-generation rancher, Minor knows the lifestyle he lives isn’t for everyone. Yet, he says it’s self-gratifying.

“The beef industry needs the family legacies to continue,” Minor says. “All of the experience and wisdom handed down generation to generation is important, and that’s what keeps the industry strong.”

Three quick tips for farm transition planning

While starting the conversation with the next generation is the first step to farm transition, Utah feedlot operator Brent Gillman, Gillman Livestock, offers these three tips as you formalize a succession plan.

1. Remember, the farm is a business. “What skills [does the next generation] have that can be an asset to the operation?” Gillman asks. Keep in mind the long-term plan for the transfer of responsibility and ownership.

2. Schedule family business meetings. “Things are always changing, so plan to have scheduled family business meetings,” Gillman says. “That way everyone who participates in the operation can get together and be involved.”

3. Clarity is key. Gillman gives this example: “Don’t be mad at someone for not doing something when there isn’t a clear description of that person’s responsibilities,” he says.

Though Gillman admits he and his dad didn’t always see eye to eye, the two always worked out their differences.

“We became really close over the years, and that’s something I hope to continue with my children,” he concludes.

Advocating and educating the next generation

While having cow-calf and feedlot operations exclusively transition to the next generation would be beneficial for the beef industry, it’s unlikely to happen given a multitude of factors, including land availability, equipment costs, labor and access to capital.

What does that mean for an industry facing an aging population of farm operators?

It means mentors are needed to help train the next generation of agriculturalists, many of whom are first-generation producers.

The situation is concerning for Angus producers like Albert Epperly, Moneta, Va. Without a next generation for his operation to transition to, Epperly is well-positioned to mentor young farmers interested in beef production.

W.E Are Farmers is a project Epperly helped create to assist the next generation of young farmers in his area who lack experience and knowledge of the industry.

“They’re mostly part-time, young people that have a lot of questions about cattle, about feeding, vaccination, all things cattle,” Epperly explains.

The group hosted its first meeting in January and is working to find solutions and encouragement for the next generation.

“Although our operation won’t have a next generation, we’re trying to put together some information and encouragement and possibilities for the next generation,” Epperly says.

Gillman also hopes to continue his family’s feedlot legacy. “It’s a good place to raise kids,” he says. “You work hard, but on the same hand, you get to spend a lot of time together.”

Independent beef producers “down on the farm” are crucial pieces to the industry. As inconvenient as succession planning is for farmers, Thummel says, we must realize our fate.

“Succession planning isn’t once and done,” she adds. “Succession planning can ebb and flow with the current circumstances, as long as all involved keep their eye on the prize of continuance.”

Editor’s note: Joann Pipkin is a freelance writer and cattlewoman from Republic, Mo.

September 2024 cover with cattle in a field

Current Angus Beef Bulletin

Articles to help you make the most of your investment in Angus genetics.

Angus At Work Color Logo

Angus at Work

A podcast for the profit-minded commercial cattleman.